Ethical Quagmire: Navigating the New Family Unity Provision in Asylum Law

Ethical Quagmire: Navigating the New Family Unity Provision in Asylum Law

Release Date: 10/18/2024
Recording Available 7-14 Days After Event Date
Format Length CLE Eligible
Video Roundtable 60 min. No

“Circumvention of Lawful Pathways,” a regulation that went into effect on May 11, 2023 created a presumption of asylum ineligibility at the southern border, has a number of exceptions allowing individuals limited access to asylum. One exception that has proven particularly difficult for asylum seekers and advocates is the family unity exception. It states that if a noncitizen can prove that they would be eligible for asylum but-for CLP, and if they have derivatives who would NOT qualify for asylum independently, the noncitizen may qualify for asylum. Under this provision, the noncitizen must show their derivatives' ineligibility for asylum - essentially undermining their asylum claims, creating a unique ethical issue. This provision also appeared in this summer’s Securing the Border regulation. This roundtable will discuss strategies to handle CLP's family unity exception with special focus on these ethical considerations.

This roundtable is presented by AILA's Asylum and Refugee Committee.


AILA Video Roundtables are free interactive learning opportunities hosted by faculty selected for their expertise, with an emphasis on discussion and Q&A. This roundtable is available only to AILA members and is not CLE eligible. The free recording will be available 7-10 business days following the live event.

Farah Al-khersan, AILA Ethics Committee Vice Chair/USCIS High Impact Adjudications Assistance Committee, Ann Arbor, MI

Gregory Fay, AILA Asylum & Refugee Committee, Phoenix, AZ

Victoria Neilson, AILA Asylum & Refugee Committee, Pleasantville, NY

Taylor Levy, Hayward, CA

The speaker's/author's views do not necessarily represent the views of AILA, nor do they constitute legal advice or representation. Practice tips provided are based on the speaker's/author's experiences and the current state of the law. Please be sure to conduct legal research and analysis for your unique situation as the law changes quickly and experiences may differ from your own.